RD813 - Emergency Management Needs Evaluation Study – 2026


Executive Summary:

In 2026, the General Assembly directed the Secretary of Public Safety and Homeland Security, in coordination with VDEM and statewide partners, to assess Virginia’s emergency management needs, evaluate the sustainability of its current funding model, and review alternative approaches used across the country. This directive comes at a time of significant transition: federal funding is becoming less predictable; disasters are increasing in frequency and complexity; and states and local governments are being asked to assume greater responsibility for preparedness, response, and recovery.

Drawing on 5 years of Local Capability Assessment for Readiness (LCAR) data, statewide risk assessments, after action reports, Regional Readiness Summit findings, federal policy analyses, and comparisons with peer states, the study identifies significant opportunities to strengthen capabilities across state, regional, and local levels. These gaps fall across 3 interdependent themes:

1.State-level capability needs.
The study identified several opportunities to strengthen Virginia’s emergency management capabilities, including managing incidents that fall below federal declaration thresholds, improving coordination across the emergency management enterprise, modernizing information sharing, strengthening public communication systems, and establishing statewide training, qualification, and resource management standards. Capability levels vary significantly across agencies and localities, complicating unified operations during major or multi-jurisdictional events.

2.Local emergency management capacity.
Local programs - especially small and rural jurisdictions - face persistent staffing shortages, uneven access to technology, and limited capability to maintain plans, conduct exercises, and sustain specialized operations. Only 19% of local programs meet all 3 LCAR staffing profile indicators (which will be discussed in depth later in this report), representing just 28% of the Virginia’s population. Federal pass-through funds have not kept pace with local needs, leaving many programs unable to invest in building capacity.

3.Integration of nongovernmental and nontraditional partners.
Private sector partners, institutions of higher education, community services boards, and nongovernmental organizations hold capabilities essential to preparedness, response, and recovery. Yet integration is ad hoc rather than systematic, and partnerships are not consistently reflected in emergency operations plans, notification systems, or real-time coordination structures. Support for populations with access and functional needs remains uneven across mission areas and is often constrained by limited funding and capacity.

The study also finds that Virginia’s emergency management enterprise is not sustainably funded. The field of emergency management has evolved from a single hazard discipline in the 1950’s, focusing primarily on civil defense issues related to a nuclear attack, to a comprehensive multi-hazard program with a host of evolving programmatic requirements that state and local government must comply with.(*1) Over the last decade, federal grants have made up nearly 92% of VDEM’s total budget, including a substantial share of core operating costs. This level of federal dependence creates significant financial risk as federal funding levels decline, awards are delayed, and federal requirements and conditions continue to evolve. Local governments face similar challenges, relying heavily on federal pass-through funding to support essential emergency management capabilities. At the same time, the FEMA Review Council’s Final Report signals a shift toward greater state and local responsibility for disaster costs and administrative functions, further increasing the need for a more sustainable state and local funding model.

In support of unified readiness, there is an immediate need for state funding for 94 current positions to sustain emergency management staffing and capabilities, reducing dependence on short-term and increasingly uncertain grant funding while ensuring long-term operational readiness. This need includes 49 positions identified in VDEM’s budget package request, consisting of 38 Emergency Management Performance Grant (EMPG)-funded positions and 11 Urban Area Security Initiative (UASI)-funded positions, an additional 11 Virginia State Police/Virginia Fusion Center positions facing grant and scope-related concerns, and 34 positions currently supported through disaster management cost recovery (20 positions) and State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) funding (14 positions). Together, these 94 positions represent the minimum staffing necessary to maintain existing services and capabilities, not future growth.

Transitioning these positions to stable state funding directly aligns with the recommendations of the SPSHS Strategic Plan and this study, both of which emphasize reducing reliance on declining federal grant programs and establishing a sustainable state funding source. It also supports priorities identified during the Unified Readiness Summit (prioritized by the 1,000 public safety leaders in attendance), where staffing emergency management with state dollars and moving positions off short-term grant funding emerged as two of the top priorities. Recent FEMA guidance further underscores the urgency of this action, including potential restrictions on using EMPG funds for salaries, increased cost-sharing burdens on states, and ongoing uncertainty surrounding federal grant programs. Funding these 94 positions with state resources will strengthen Virginia’s readiness posture, provide workforce stability, reduce operational risk, and ensure the Commonwealth can continue delivering critical preparedness, response, recovery, and mitigation services regardless of fluctuations in federal funding.

Strategic Recommendations

The study provides a set of strategic recommendations aligned to the 3 themes and the funding analysis that would most effectively strengthen Virginia’s emergency management enterprise. These recommendations represent the most critical actions Virginia can take to improve emergency management capability, resilience, and fiscal sustainability:

Build and sustain emergency management capabilities at the state level.
Implement the Unified Readiness Framework; develop a statewide capability inventory with documented activation pathways; modernize information sharing and technology systems; establish statewide staffing, planning, and training standards; and clarify resource-deployment criteria for non-declared incidents.

Strengthen local capacity.
Fund minimum local staffing requirements, incentivize plan maintenance, expand access to training and exercises, formalize local-to-local mutual aid, support local mitigation projects, and sustain recovery and hazard mitigation expertise at state and local levels.

Better integrate nongovernmental and nontraditional partners.
Create a dedicated private sector integration program; formalize partnerships with critical infrastructure, nongovernmental organizations, and institutions of higher education; enhance information sharing and notification systems; and invest in preparedness initiatives that support populations with access and functional needs.

Modernize Virginia’s emergency management funding model.
Establish stable, recurring state support that reduces reliance on federal grants and equitably supports local, regional, and statewide emergency management capabilities, including incidents below federal assistance thresholds. The model should also improve coordination and tracking of public investments and the significant resources contributed by volunteer organizations and private sector partners.

Many of the findings in this study echo conclusions identified more than 3 decades ago in the Commonwealth’s 1994 State of Preparedness in Virginia for a Catastrophic Disaster report. While Virginia’s emergency management capabilities have expanded substantially since that time, driven by improved planning, stronger partnerships, and advancements in technology, several long-standing gaps and vulnerabilities persist. The continuity of these challenges across multiple generations of emergency management professionals underscores the need for sustained investment and structural modernization to ensure Virginia is prepared for increasingly complex and consequential disasters.

This study provides a path forward: a readiness model that is resilient, modernized, and sustainably funded—positioning Virginia to protect its communities, infrastructure, economy, and quality of life in an era of accelerating risk.

Virginia has built substantial capability through years of state, local, and intergovernmental partnership. Yet Virginia now faces a critical inflection point. Virginia’s emergency management enterprise must adapt to a more complex risk landscape, growing operational demands, and an evolving federal role. Sustained state investment, stronger local capacity, and purposeful integration of nongovernmental partners are essential to ensuring that Virginia is equipped to mitigate, prepare for, respond to, and recover from future disasters.

This study provides a path forward: a readiness model that is resilient, modernized, and sustainably funded—positioning Virginia to protect its communities, infrastructure, economy, and quality of life in an era of accelerating risk.
_________________________________________________
(*1) Department of Emergency Services, State of Preparedness in Virginia for a Catastrophic Disaster, House Document No. 21, (Richmond, VA: Commonwealth of Virginia, 1994), 32. https://rga.lis.virginia.gov/Published/1994/HD21-PDF.