RD814 - Department of Taxation Study of Penny Rounding Pursuant to House Bill 954 Report – November 1, 2026


Executive Summary:

Purpose and Scope

This report fulfills the directive in the third enactment of House Bill (HB) 954 requiring the Department of Taxation (“Virginia Tax") to evaluate options and recommend a uniform statewide procedure for localities to adjust bills and account balances for taxes and other charges paid by cash transactions following the cessation of penny production by the United States Mint. Virginia Tax was further directed to report its findings and recommendations to the Chairs of the Senate Committee on Finance and Appropriations and the House Committee on Appropriations no later than November 1, 2026. A copy of the enacted legislative mandate is attached as Appendix A.

HB 954 provides localities temporary authority to adopt rounding procedures through July 1, 2027. To develop recommendations for a permanent statewide framework, Virginia Tax considered the legislative history of HB 954, international and multistate approaches to cash rounding, discussion at the July 23, 2026 workgroup meeting, final survey responses from localities and other governmental entities, and the estimated fiscal effects of alternative rounding methods.

Key Findings

The final survey included responses from 43 unique localities, of which 34 reported accepting cash payments. Survey responses generally support the need for a uniform statewide approach. Among cash-accepting respondents, 91 percent reported either having no local rounding procedure or waiting for a statewide procedure. Among respondents expressing a preference between the two principal rounding approaches, 79 percent preferred symmetric nearest-nickel rounding.

The survey also identified differences in billing-system capabilities, treatment of small residual balances, installment payments, and implementation readiness. These differences indicate that permanent legislation should establish a consistent statewide rule while providing sufficient clarity for localities and their system vendors to implement it.

Recommendation

The workgroup recommends a uniform statewide procedure using symmetric nearest-nickel rounding for cash payments. Under this approach, amounts ending in one or two cents or six or seven cents would round down; amounts ending in three or four cents or eight or nine cents would round up; and amounts ending in zero or five cents would remain unchanged.

Rounding should apply only to the final cash payment amount and should not alter the calculation, reporting, or remittance of the underlying tax or charge. Non-cash payments capable of being settled to the exact cent should remain unaffected. Permanent legislation should also provide clear authority and procedures for addressing sub-nickel residual balances resulting from cash rounding.

Additional issues requiring clarification include the definition of a cash transaction, third-party cash payment channels, the timing of rounding, installment payments, penalty and interest, public notice, and implementation timing. These matters are discussed in greater detail in the body of this report.