RD838 - Evaluation of Virginia’s Nursing Home Workforce and Considerations for a State Nursing Home Staffing Standard
Executive Summary: FINDINGS IN BRIEF State and federal regulations are meant to ensure the health and safety of nursing home residents Nursing homes serve individuals with significant nursing care needs who cannot be safely supported in less intensive care settings. State and federal regulations set standards for the type and quality of care nursing home residents should receive and establish the process for monitoring compliance with those regulations. State and federal regulations do not establish specific staffing standards for nursing staff. State complaint investigators point to insufficient nursing staff as the root cause of many complaints about resident quality of care in nursing homes. Nurse staffing levels and nursing skill mix drive quality of care in nursing homes A substantial body of evidence associates higher nurse staffing levels and balanced nursing skill mix in nursing homes with improvements in quality of care and resident health outcomes, such as reduced pressure ulcers, urinary tract infections, and hospitalizations. Registered nurses (RNs) demonstrate the strongest relationship with resident quality of care, followed by certified nurse aides (CNAs). While licensed practical nurses (LPNs) provide important services in nursing homes, the statistical relationship between LPN hours alone and quality of care is not consistent. Nurse staffing levels and nursing skill mix are inadequate in some of Virginia’s nursing homes Virginia’s average nurse staffing level for nursing homes falls below the national average. In addition, the nursing skill mix in Virginia nursing homes is imbalanced, with higher levels of LPN staffing and lower levels of RN and CNA staffing. Virginia nursing homes also report higher turnover rates among all nursing staff and among RNs compared to the national average. Virginia’s lower-staffed nursing homes have lower quality ratings. Virginia funds incentive programs to address nursing home workforce shortages Persistent nursing workforce shortages across Virginia’s health care settings impacts nursing home staffing levels. The nursing home workforce has returned to pre-pandemic levels but the longstanding gap between nursing supply and demand remains. Virginia offers scholarship and loan repayment programs for nursing staff in long-term care settings and a value-based purchasing program for nursing homes. Most states have staffing standards for nursing homes Staffing standards are one tool states can use to improve quality of care by requiring nursing homes to meet minimum nurse staffing levels. When states tie staffing standards to the process for licensing nursing homes, states see improvements in staffing with few negative consequences. Thirty-two states and Washington, D.C. have enacted a staffing standard. Virginia enacted a nursing home staffing standard in 2023, then repealed it when the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) established federal staffing standards. Virginia should re-establish a nursing home staffing standard Virginia does not require nursing homes to meet a staffing standard even as compelling evidence supports higher nurse staffing levels. The General Assembly could address this gap by re-establishing a staffing standard that increases nurse staffing levels and improves skill mix in Virginia nursing homes. Coupling staffing standards with funding to address the anticipated increased costs of care and considerations for enforcement, increased accountability, policy evaluation, and support for the nursing workforce may ease implementation and feasibility concerns and amplify the effectiveness of staffing standards over time. POLICY OPTIONS IN BRIEF Option: Establish a nursing home staffing standard that includes the following thresholds: • Beginning Fiscal Year 2029, 3.09 adjusted total nurse staffing hours per resident day (HPRD), • Beginning Fiscal Year 2031, 3.32 adjusted total nurse staffing HPRD, including 0.54 adjusted RN staffing HPRD and 2.06 adjusted CNA staffing HPRD, and • Beginning Fiscal Year 2034, 3.43 adjusted total nurse staffing HPRD, including 0.60 adjusted RN staffing HPRD and 2.23 adjusted CNA staffing HPRD. (Option 1, page 24) Additional Options: If the JCHC recommends establishing a staffing standard, the JCHC could also: • Establish a hardship fund for nursing homes unable to meet the Fiscal Year 2029 threshold (Option 1a, page 29) • Make the Fiscal Years 2031 and 2034 thresholds contingent upon additional state appropriations (Option 1b, page 31) • Require the Board of Health to promulgate regulations incorporating staffing standards in the state’s licensing requirements (Option 1c, page 32) • Establish a good faith exception for nursing homes unable to meet the staffing standard (Option 1d, page 32) • Provide funding to the Virginia Department of Health (VDH) to increase the agency’s capacity to enforce the staffing standard (Option 1e, page 33) • Require the Department of Medical Assistance Services (DMAS) to collect information from nursing homes on how additional public funds are used to support the nursing workforce (Option 1f, page 33) • Provide funding to VDH to evaluate the impact of the staffing standard (Option 1g, page 34) • Require DMAS to update the Nursing Facility Value-Based Purchasing Program’s thresholds for staffing measures to align with the state staffing standard (Option 1h, page 34) |