RD839 - Virginia’s Liquid Nicotine and Nicotine Vapor Product Directory
Executive Summary: FINDINGS IN BRIEF Nicotine vapor product use is increasing among adults, and use can lead to short- and long-term health harms Nicotine vapor products vaporize liquids containing nicotine and other substances, including flavorings or illegal compounds, for inhalation by the user. In Virginia, the number of adults using nicotine vapor products has increased while combustible cigarette smoking has decreased since 2016. Rates of youth nicotine vapor product use have fallen since the passing of Tobacco 21 in 2019, but underage use still occurs. Use of liquid nicotine and nicotine vapor products is associated with higher risk of lung disease, worsened respiratory conditions, and potential long-term cardiovascular harm. The FDA regulates new nicotine vapor products offered for sale in the U.S., but enforcement and product seizures are limited The federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates new tobacco products offered for retail sale in the United States through the Premarket Tobacco Product Application (PMTA) process. The FDA is responsible for bringing forth enforcement actions on those in violation of PMTA requirements. Enforcement mechanisms are designed to keep unregulated products out of retail markets, but significant application backlogs and inconsistent enforcement have resulted in few product approvals and limited products seizures. This has allowed for the continued availability of unregulated products, which can result in harm to the public due to the exposure to unknown ingredients, deceptive labeling, or faulty equipment. Virginia established the Directory to limit access to unregulated products Virginia’s Liquid Nicotine and Nicotine Vapor Product Directory (the Directory) offers the Commonwealth greater authority to ensure unregulated nicotine vapor products are not accessible to consumers through its own enforcement framework. However, legal challenges have delayed implementation of the Directory, and resources and procedural limitations may hinder enforcement at the local level. While thirteen states have implemented directory laws, many have faced implementation or legal challenges that limit the amount of available data necessary to evaluate the impact of such a directory. Additional evidence is required to evaluate the effectiveness of the Directory in meeting its purpose of reducing access to unregulated liquid nicotine and nicotine vapor products in the Commonwealth. POLICY OPTIONS IN BRIEF Option: Require the Attorney General to include additional information about the Liquid Nicotine and Nicotine Vapor Product Directory (the Directory) and enforcement actions related to the Directory in its annual report. (Option 1, page 18) Option: Provide funding to the Virginia Foundation for Healthy Youth to establish a contract with a third-party evaluator to conduct a comprehensive assessment of the impact of the Liquid Nicotine and Nicotine Vapor Product Directory on access to unregulated nicotine vapor products in Virginia and Virginia’s nicotine vapor product market. (Option 2, page 19) |